Rand Fishkin is the co-founder of SparkToro and previously built Moz to $50M ARR—before stepping away and rethinking everything about how he works, hires, and grows a company.
Today, SparkToro is a 3-person, profitable SaaS business doing $1.5M+ in revenue, and it’s intentionally calm: no cold calls, no demos, and no aggressive sales playbooks.
In this episode, Rand explains how to grow sustainably without chasing scale, how he leveraged brand to jumpstart SparkToro, and why product, not integrations, features, or funnels, is the real growth engine.
Topics we cover in this episode:
Why SparkToro doesn’t offer demos and still grows fast
How Rand built a waitlist of 14,000+ on day one
The tradeoffs of calm growth: fewer integrations, higher churn
How to design a business around what you’re good at
What Rand would do differently if starting today
Why founder-led marketing still works—and how to scale it
Rand’s take on AI, competitive risk, and moving slowly on purpose
Product-market fit is a journey, not a destination
Don't forget to subscribe to the podcast for more insights from industry leaders reshaping B2B SaaS and marketing!
Connect with Rand:
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/randfishkin/
SparkToro: https://sparktoro.com/
Rand’s book - Lost and Founder: https://www.amazon.com/Lost-Founder-Rand-Fishkin/dp/0735213321
Snackbar Studio: https://snackbarstudio.com/
Connect with me:
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/finnthormeier/
Website: https://www.project33.io/
Podcast: https://open.spotify.com/show/03CXzsZp7wdqIRVDcqPTFH
Chapters:
00:00 Building Moz to $50M ARR → Starting Over at SparkToro
01:35 Founder strengths, weaknesses, and designing around them
04:10 Why Rand stopped taking sales calls (and what happened)
07:12 Hiring for cultural fit, not just talent
09:24 Intentional product limits—and accepting churn
12:30 The “rules for business life” Rand wrote before SparkToro
14:15 Why calm companies make better decisions
17:21 Product is 80%. Here’s what the rest looks like
19:37 Do you need a founder-led marketing motion?
22:20 Building brands without being the face
25:08 Launch strategy: how Rand got 14,000 waitlist signups
26:22 What changed after Rand’s Moz exit windfall
28:01 Is financial comfort a requirement for calm growth?
30:26 How Rand would grow SparkToro if he started at zero
31:27 The role of content, Reddit, YouTube, and cross-posting
34:36 Why Reddit is a B2B marketing cheat code
36:14 Should technical founders learn marketing, or just hire?
38:58 SparkToro vs. SnackBar: building in different industries
Full Transcript:
Finn Thormeier: Rand, you, you started and ran Moz from 2001 to 2017. The stat that I found is build it to roughly 50 million in, in ARR. Uh, then there was this whole story around you leaving, being ousted, not being ousted, leaving on your own terms. But either way, you, you left Moz and you started SparkToro in 2018. And, uh, I think you guys are still only a team of three. Is that correct? You and your co-founder and, and, uh, Amanda.
Rand Fishkin: That’s right. Yeah, just the three of us. Yep.
Finn Thormeier: Very cool. I want to talk... I know that probably some of you guys joined here for, you know, brand awareness, content, social search, because obviously, Rand, you have, I mean, unlimited amount of expertise there. I would really love to explore just this transition from VC-backed hustle to small, profitable, calm company. So you guys in the audience, Mike, Ingga, Chris, Michael, if you want to just drop a couple keywords on, like, the topics that you’re most interested in from Rand’s perspective, so I can try to navigate a little bit and not only talk about what I find most interesting. And you can obviously at any point drop in a question, and also the people who are watching from the live stream, you guys can drop in a question too, and I’ll go there. Okay, first question. So when you left Moz, you wrote that, and I quote, “With SparkToro, you resolved to completely overhaul how you designed a business, its goals and its operations.” What were, like, the, what, what was that overhaul? What were some of the key differences, decisions that you put in place?
Rand Fishkin: Well, I think one thing was, for a long time, Moz, my previous company, my first company, was quite founder marketing. But as we scaled up, as we took venture, there was a forcing function to diversify the marketing efforts, right? You can’t just be reliant on the founder. The founder can leave, can be pushed out, can get hit by a bus, right? And, and obviously your investors, who put in tens of millions of dollars, need their investment secured. So we hired a lot of people into our marketing team, we tried to diversify that, we put a lot of effort into paid and performance marketing, which never was hugely successful for us. I think that, as I wrote in Lost and Founder, uh, startups inherit the DNA, positive and negative, of their founders. And Moz inherited my natural predilection for content marketing and SEO and social media marketing and video marketing, and it also inherited my core weakness, which is paid and performance, something I’ve never been good at, never really been interested in. And I think because of that, you know, the business just wasn’t built around it, and it never benefited all that much. I think at the, at the tip top of our spend, maybe, maybe performance marketing was responsible for 15 to 20% of signups.
Finn Thormeier: Mhm.
Rand Fishkin: Now, when we transition, when I transitioned to SparkToro, I just gave myself permission to do what I’m good at. Which, I think there’s two ways to think about this. Like, you can fight against your natural instincts, you can fight against your natural sort of strengths and weaknesses, or you can just embrace them. And I think if you want to build a calm company and you want to love what you do, it’s kind of great to embrace the thing that you’re great at and supplement the things that you’re bad at with other people, or build a company that doesn’t need you to be good at those things. And that is, that is exactly the intention behind SparkToro, is basically build a company that has no need for the kinds of things that I don’t love to do and I’m not good at.
Finn Thormeier: One of the classic advices is, you know, in the beginning you need to kind of do whatever it takes. So you need to do marketing and sales and HR and finance and everything as a founder, right? And then eventually, hopefully, you grow to a point where you can just outsource, delegate, and hire for the things that you don’t enjoy or the things that you’re not good at. But you guys are only a team of three. So it’s not like you have a team where you can just be like, “You do the finance, and you do the HR, and you do this and this, and I’ll only do marketing.” How do you think about, like, like, is it as simple as saying, “If I don’t enjoy doing client calls, I should just not run an agency, and that’s the wrong business for me to be in”? Or, like, how do you do that when you’re only three people?
Rand Fishkin: Yeah. Yeah. So I want to be clear. I, I think the wrong word here is “not do it at all.” That is too extreme. The right way to phrase it is “minimize it and minimize the need for it.” So I, I’m not good at paid and performance marketing. We haven’t really invested in that. We, we did some trials with, like, an outsourced agency. They, they haven’t been super successful yet. So, we’re, you know, still considering whether we want to invest there. But, for example, sales calls. So, this was something that early on we did do. And I saw a question someone asked about how did you get your first big customers, Mike? Yeah. So, Mike, we, what I tried to do, what I thought would be the right thing to do, is to have those enterprise sales type calls to, you know, people reach out. They say, “Hey, I checked out SparkToro. The product looks really interesting, but I’d love someone to walk me through it.” And I probably did, I think in our first 12 to 16 months, I did maybe 60 or 70 of those types of calls with people who wrote in. So, you know, it wasn’t outreach, it wasn’t external me pitching people, but it was people who had come to us, asked for this. You want to know what the close rate on that is for me? My close rate of those approximately 80, we had two signups. Every day SparkToro got five or six signups with no sales call. So what the hell was I doing? Right? Like, just put effort into the thing that’s working. And, and when people, now, when people write in, for the last 3 years, when people have written into SparkToro, myself or Amanda or Casey will write back and say, “I’m sorry, we don’t offer demos. Here’s some videos you can check out.” It works out fine.
Finn Thormeier: I, I want... So it, it’s... What do you do? I feel like it’s easier if you do 60 demos, you only close two, because you can kind of say, “I don’t enjoy it, and I’m bad at it.” What do you do if you do 60 demos and you close 30 and you don’t
Enjoy it?
Rand Fishkin: Well, I would, I would then probably tell you, is there a way you could modify what you do to be, to make it more enjoyable, right? Do you got to change up the style? Do you want to make those calls? Is it something where, hey, I’m really good at it, so I can train somebody to do this, and then, and then I can do, basically, be good at this thing that I don’t have to personally do myself? Which I think is another excellent way to, you know, build a long-lasting successful company.
Finn Thormeier: Yeah. By the way, just for people, for context, um, I don’t, I know you don’t talk about that, but I think the last publicly shared number that I saw was 1.5 million ARR, that we’re in that range.
Rand Fishkin: Yep.
Finn Thormeier: Okay. So, you know, when I say three people, so people have an idea that...
Rand Fishkin: Yeah. We’re not doing, we’re not doing, like, $10 million of revenue or anything. No. No.
Finn Thormeier: But I’m saying, I think when most people hear three people, they might think much smaller numbers than, than...
Rand Fishkin: Ah. Ah, I see. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
Finn Thormeier: So, okay. What were the other... So you talked about the focus on what you’re good at. Did you put any limitations on other, limitations on the company, like, “We’re not going to do any internal calls, we’re not going to...” from the lessons at Moz, that contributed to building a calm company?
Rand Fishkin: Yeah. Um, I mean, a big one, for sure, was that we wanted to limit overhead and management, which meant that anybody that we brought onto the team, myself and Casey included, were very, I would say, focused, responsible. You can completely sort of trust us to do our work. We don’t need check-ins. I’ll, I’ll tell you the day, this, the minute that, uh, Casey and I were sold on hiring Amanda, ‘cuz she pitched us, right? She came to us and said, “Hey, I should be Spark’s first employee. Let me tell you why.” And when she said, “I don’t love managers who check in with me. Like, if you’re worried about something, let me know, of course. But if I’m worried about something, if I have an issue, if I’m struggling in my work, if I want to tell you what I’m doing, I’m just going to tell you. You don’t need to check in.” And we went, “Yep, that’s, that’s the person for us,” right? That is exactly the kind of, of hire. So, I think one of those is leaning into cultural fit, right? Just saying, hey, this is how we are. We’re not going to try and sort of arbitrarily hire the, the 10x person. We’re going to hire the 10x culture fit, the fit for us, not the, you know, what, whatever we think is the most dreamy candidate by some, you know, external metric.
Um, another thing that was a big deal for us with SparkToro was building a product that had a lot of, what am I going to say? No need for intense uptime, maintenance, and stressful situations. So, our product does not interact or engage with anything on our customers’ end. Like, they don’t have to plug it into their analytic system. They don’t have to add it to their CMS. They’re not, you know, authorizing their credit card payment processing system. It’s not, there’s no pixel sitting in their website. It’s in an entirely external tool. If it goes down, which has happened, I don’t know, a couple hours out of every year. So, Casey’s very good at uptime, but people don’t really notice or care. Like, it’s not that big a deal. If you can’t access SparkToro for an hour, you do it tomorrow. You, you know, you run your report again later. We’ve occasionally had someone say, “Hey, this report’s hanging for me.” But nobody stresses out if we don’t reply for, you know, until the next morning. So, that, that was another big component.
I’m going to say this, that intentionally limits revenue and churn reduction opportunities, right? Like, we have built a product that does not, because it doesn’t connect into lots of, of other systems, it also loses out on the “Hey, this is hard to replace. It’s a pain in the ass to, like, take it out of our system, so let’s just keep paying for it.” And so, as a result, our churn rate is quite high. People use us when they need us. They quit when they don’t need us. They sign back up when they need us again. We also, like, we got to a headspace where we’re really comfortable with that. And right now, today, I think a lot of people are shocked to find out that 20% of our customers who sign up every month have been customers before. And so for us, lifetime value is not lifetime of one subscription. It’s lifetime across the life of a customer’s multiple subscription periods. And almost everyone is a multi-time customer.
Finn Thormeier: Yeah. Uh, was this, so, so did you actually, after, after leaving Moz, sit down, and this whole idea around not being this kind of mission-critical, integrated-with-all-of-their-tools type of thing, was that a thing that you wrote down, you journaled about, and then Sparked Toro? Or was that, like, a pivot you made later, or just happened naturally?
Rand Fishkin: Yeah, I, uh, it was more intentional. So basic, Casey and I got together, I want to say, maybe five to 10 times, at restaurants and cafes, and, you know, go out for a drink, meet up at the office, like, whatever. And we wrote down kind of all these things. I actually have it in a notebook, um, I think back in my hotel room. Uh, have it in a notebook where I’ve, where I’ve written down kind of all these things that we believe will be true, both about the market and about ourselves, and what we want, and what we’re trying to build. And then kind of taking those, almost like rules for business life, and turning them into a company, and making sure that, that they aligned. And so that, that actually turned into our, our core values at SparkToro, which, uh, we wrote a blog post about. But, um, it’s more for us than for external people, and I, I don’t want to suggest that everyone or anyone listening needs to use what we use. But I do think it is incredibly valuable to have a set of core values that you stick to as a company. Ours are called Belux. That’s an acronym. Um, and you can, you can search for “Spark core values” and read through them if you want. But yeah, I mean, one of the, the first letter in Belux is boundaries. We are very boundaried about our work and about our work lives and our personal lives.
Finn Thormeier: And so how do you think... And yes, go for it.
Rand Fishkin: No, I was going to say, I realize that’s unusual to say when
I’m, when I’m supposed to be kind of on a mini vacation after a work week here in Italy, but, you know, the Geraldine’s over at Gelatia, so she’ll be fine.
Finn Thormeier: I mean, I asked you and you said yes. So, yeah.
Rand Fishkin: Yeah, that was perfect. Yeah, the European timing is great.
Finn Thormeier: There we go. Um, how do you think about it? It feels like SaaS is becoming more and more competitive, more and more fast-moving. All of these AI tools, and it’s so easy to build features, and new products popping up left and right. How do you think about you being able to run a calm small company when maybe, I don’t know, someone looks at SparkToro and says, “I’ll build this. I’ll use ChatGPT. I’ll work 80 hours a week. I will not have weekends. I will not have work-life balance. I will maybe raise some VC, VC money and hire a team of 10 engineers and 20 marketers, etc., etc.”? Do you worry about that? How do you think about the sustainability of... Tell me, yeah, give me your point of view.
Rand Fishkin: Let’s see. I, I don’t worry about it at all. I think if anyone were to raise venture in our particular sector, right, audience research software, as you mentioned, right, we’re doing somewhere around, you know, north of one, less than $2 million, and we’re the biggest player in this tiny little market. Who would, who would poss, who could ever fund a company where, you know, this sector is teeny-tiny? And very frankly, let’s say someone did build a product and it were very competitive, let’s say it was a better product than SparkToro. What could they charge more? Are there enough more customers out there for them? Are they going to, um, are they going to be able to build a brand? Like, will people have heard of them? I think it would take a long time and an incredible amount of effort to build up the marketing and brand recognition. Whereas, you know, I, I’m sort of spoiled in that when I left Moz, I knew that, that the next day tons of people, you know, tens of thousands, I don’t know, hundreds of thousands of people would be paying attention to what is Rand doing next. And so I waited to essentially announce my departure from Moz until I could time it exactly with starting SparkToro.
Finn Thormeier: Mhm.
Rand Fishkin: And so this way, kind of, kind of bring my audience with me, um, and get that, get that bump, which, which was very helpful. Those, you know, we had about 14,000 people on the SparkToro, like, “I want to have this product” wait list when we launched in 2020. And those became our first 500 customers and basically got us to break-even profitability in about 7 months.
Finn Thormeier: Mhm.
Rand Fishkin: I, I’m not saying I have no fear of competition. I think somebody else could, you know, some big player in the field, a, a Similarweb or, um, Semrush or, you know, somebody like that, could go and build us kind of as a feature. But if they really want to do that, they, they should probably buy us, right? Like, and, and also, you know, one to $2 million in revenue, like, it’s not, it’s not moving the needle for anybody.
Finn Thormeier: I mean, I guess where I’m also trying to get at is, is it just, okay, you, let’s say you, you, you picked a market where the market opportunity isn’t so big, so it’s not very attractive for VC money, but there could still be some 20-year-old, some 20-some who’s working 80 hours a week, and, and I guess we’re, was trying to get a...
Rand Fishkin: Have you, have you seen, Finn, have you seen a lot of those people disrupt a lot of, uh, I don’t know, calm companies?
Finn Thormeier: I have not. I have not seen that. Not, not in any sector.
Rand Fishkin: I know there’s a belief, Silicon Valley brand...
Finn Thormeier: Is it, is it that because you guys are moving, let’s say, more slowly, more calmly, you’re making better decisions, and so actually you’re doing better work?
Rand Fishkin: Yes. I, I entirely, I entirely believe that it is. Because when I was stressed out, when I was working 80-hour weeks at Moz, when I was, you know, putting way, way too much of my sort of personal value of my life, like, who am I as a person, why, why do I matter in this world, into the company, I, I think I was making the worst business decisions, uh, of my life. And you can see some of the results of those. I’ve, I’ve written postmortems about the Moz experience, including in Lost and Founder. Um, and I think that being in a comfortable, relaxed position with investors who are looking for a, you know, two to 3x return and would be thrilled with anything more than that, um, and already got their money back, you know, from us, that’s, that’s just a happy place to be. Like, it’s a very, we can look at the market and we can say, for example, AI. AI is, like, a big thing where we have observed people switching away from SparkToro to AI, and, and thankfully, thank god, coming back to us, because they basically realized that, that what ChatGPT or, or Bard or Gemini or any of these other ones are doing is not giving real information about an audience, but rather sort of predictive, right, you know, words that come after other words.
And the, the nice thing about that has been, we can, we’ve sort of watched that market for a few years now, and at this point we’ve found some use cases among our customers where we think, “Hey, these actually are pretty smart things our customers are already doing with SparkToro plus AI tools. Let’s add that into the product as a feature. Like, let’s make that a seamless experience, so that it’s even more comfortable and sort of friendly to use SparkToro and AI together.” Um, and that, you know, I think that comes from having patience. As opposed to, if, if I had been venture-backed 2 years ago, 3 years ago, I would have been panicking, man. I would have been, like, freaking out like everybody else. My venture, my venture board would have been breathing down my neck saying, “How are you going to use AI? Why isn’t it on your homepage? You know, this, you need to change your whole strategy.” Yeah. And I think that would have been dumb.
Finn Thormeier: I think who else comes to mind is 37signals, Basecamp. I think they have not launched a single AI-powered feature so far.
Rand Fishkin: Pretty, pretty impressive, right? And, like, I don’t think their revenue’s gone down.
Finn Thormeier: Yeah. Um, if you are constrain, if you want to build a calm company, you’re constrained by working 40 hours, 30 hours a week, you want to travel, you don’t want to do certain kinds of things, like hopping on sales calls, you want to
Make slow decisions, have the time to think. So, you have lots of constraints that maybe another person just pushes through or whatever. What are the things to focus on that actually matter, that really have an impact, that prioritize properly, so that in that constraints you still are able to build a meaningful company and be profitable and grow, etc.?
Rand Fishkin: Um, I think I have, I’ve come around to the belief that product is 80% of everything. Um, and that essentially the, the work that we do designing the product, the interface, which data pieces are included in the product, which ones aren’t, how we present information visually, um, what the data sources are, how we can prove our work. You know, I, I know there’s people who are like, “Product is everything.” I, I don’t believe that. I still strongly believe in marketing. I, I mean, everyone, everyone in this room, everyone who’s listening to this has used Adobe PDF. That is a terrible product. A godamn terrible product in every single way. Anybody who tells you product is everything, like, I just point to Adobe PDF. I’m like, “Well, I don’t know, bro.” Um, but 80%, absolutely. And certainly for startups and challenger brands that are, like, trying to make an impact. So product work comes first and foremost for us.
Secondarily, after that, is the hard work of introducing people to the concept of audience research. Finding the right customer, and then learning the pathways and delivery mechanisms that we need to use to reach them, and build a resonant message, marketing message. So that’s who are we right for, who are we not right for. It’s what, what sorts of messages, when we talk about our product, like, they’re really into it. They’re like, “Oh yeah, I need that. I use that. That’s valuable to me.” Like, I get it. Um, we, we also think really hard about the which use cases we do and don’t want to serve, and nailing that stuff. So yeah, a lot of that, I think, what’s called product-market fit work is, in my opinion, there’s no such thing as product-market fit. It does not exist. It is a journey, not a destination. You don’t get there. We don’t have fit and then we do. You are always trying to get a better fit with the right customers, and that is the most important work we do.
Finn Thormeier: All right, let’s get to... I’ve been monopolizing the conversation here. Let’s get to some. So, Eningga, you said “transitioning to founder-led marketing.” Do you want to frame your question here or give a little bit more context?
Audience Member (Ingga): So, I’m not a founder. I work for founder companies. Um, so I am, uh, I’ve been doing this for 15 years or so. And one of the things that’s always interesting to me, and it’s a particular challenge today, actually, is just how do you, if you don’t have a natural sort of founder marketer, or even founder-led salesperson, how do you actually get that person into that? Or is there an alternative strategy that you can use? ‘Cuz...
Rand Fishkin: Yeah, I think, you know, I feel, I feel your pain. I generally, I’m going to go back to the answer I gave earlier about sort of that companies inheriting the DNA, positive and negative, of, of their founders. And I think that in many cases is the right thing to do, can be to find marketing channels that fit with the strengths of the business, rather than trying to force-fit a founder-ledd style of marketing onto a founder who’s not a marketer.
Audience Member (Ingga): Yeah. What would you think, like, give me an, can you give me an example?
Rand Fishkin: Sure. Yeah, absolutely. I, I think that many forms of paid and performance marketing, social media advertising, um, content advertising, LinkedIn ads, um, buying email lists from people, sponsoring events, you know, brand investments, outdoor, you know, all, all sorts of stuff.
Audience Member (Ingga): All of the standard non-founder marketing things.
Rand Fishkin: Yeah. Yeah. And you can also invest in a lot of what founder-led marketing is, is content marketing at its core.
Audience Member (Ingga): Right. Right. Yeah. Thought leadership. Like, thought leadership: who’s the best in this industry, knows more than anything? I want to get him out there, and it’s, yeah, I want to get him out there talking about everything he knows, and his, you know, amazing, you know, all that good stuff.
Rand Fishkin: Yeah, not easy. Uh, I think, I think that that can be replaced with great research. Like, press loves research, uh, social media world loves research, especially in B2B. I also think it can be replaced with, in the, in the B2C fields, you can see a ton of what I’d call mimetic marketing, right? Meme-based marketing, um, things that are likely to get some virality or some play on social media. They use current events wisely. They intelligently play on trends. They use, you know, kind of youth culture in smart ways. That stuff works really well. So for Ingga, I’ll tell you, for me, I have no, absolutely zero presence in the world of video games. I’ve never done a video game before. I’m a useless founder marketer for Snackbar, right? For, for Snackbar Studio. And so instead, I’ve been interviewing a bunch of agencies, consultants, marketers in that field, and talking to them about, like, “Hey, how do you do what you do? What, what are the sort of steps for success?” And I, I found that process to be fascinating, but it is, it is no founder content, right?
Audience Member (Ingga): So we’re sort of flipping that almost, and what I’m trying to do right now is flip that almost, is that, you know, we’re bringing in, like, customers, for example, for our founder to do an interview with the customer, where he’s not exactly speaking all of the time, and it’s in his comfort zone, and he loves talking about, you know, these super technical kind of things. And it leaves our customers being the star a little bit, but I still sort of get to have his, you know, unique perspective on the industry that we’re in and the business we’re in. That’s, that’s our next stab at that.
Rand Fishkin: I don’t think that’s a bad idea. And I, I also want to say, you’ve got to give yourself sort of the permission and forgiveness to try and fail at a bunch of stuff. Like, yes. Right. Like, this takes a long...
Audience Member (Ingga): Okay. Good. Good. Good. Good.
Rand Fishkin: Yeah. I think there’s, this is another, this is another strong point, going back to what we were talking about, Finn. Right. This is another really strong point of a calm company, is the, the forgiveness and permission to fail and learn and try again, and to, to move more slowly, to not have to be, and, and to not burn out when you’re doing it. That’s a, it’s a shocking advantage over a lot of folks who, look, I mean, I, I wrote about the, the statistics in venture, and they’ve gotten worse since I wrote Lost and Founder, which
Is, I think it’s 90, 95 out of a hundred venture-backed startups will not return 1x. They won’t even earn the money that was invested to them.
Finn Thormeier: Yeah. Do you, Rand, do you have growth goals? Like, do you set certain things that you want to achieve?
Rand Fishkin: We do. It’s, it’s moderately informal. We have kind of a, you know, annual thing in January where Amanda and Casey and I have a chat about our performance last year, do a little post-mortem on things, and we sort of try and predict the year ahead. This year we are predicting quite low growth, mostly because of the new American administration and our expectation that the global economy will suffer quite a bit because of that. But, um, yeah, we do, we have kind of a, a process for that.
Finn Thormeier: All right, Michael, you had a, you, you wrote something in it alongside the, the, the GTM journey. Did you have a question, um, on that for Rand?
Audience Member (Michael): Uh, actually, he answered it before, when he said, like, um, he, he timed the launch with his exits.
Rand Fishkin: So yeah, I, I think that’s a really strong technique. Other thing, the other thing I would do, and we’re doing this for Snackbar Studio, for example, Michael, is, um, I strongly, strongly recommend getting, like, all your emails of all the people you’ve ever worked with, who know you, who like you, who trust you, who think highly of you. Have those sitting in a sort of, you know, doc of some kind, an Excel or a spreadsheet, kind of ready for you to tap into your own personal kind of LinkedIn. A lot of people can’t use LinkedIn this way because, you know, they accept too many connections or whatever. Those people aren’t really in there. But that is a superpower, being able to email 500 people, even 50 people in your network, and say, “Hey, I’m launching this thing.” Don’t send it as a BCC. Don’t put them all in a group. Email each one individually. It is worth the time and effort to send one email to one, right? Like, when I launch Snackbar, Finn, I’m so sorry about this, but you’re going to get an email, and the email is going to say, “Hey, Finn, we’re launching our video game. Would you go check it out?” Like, that would be a huge favor to me.
Finn Thormeier: I will check it out.
Rand Fishkin: Yeah. I, I mean, I think you’re going to love it, but also that, that one-to-one, um, is so powerful. And when people are on a BCC, they, they just ignore it, even if they’re your best friend.
Audience Member (Michael): Yeah, I agree. It looks like, um, in personal, actually.
Rand Fishkin: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Exactly.
Finn Thormeier: But add me on the email list, please. All right, we’ll do, drop your email now if you want to, if you want to be notified about, um... Or can people sign up to some wait list somewhere on your website?
Rand Fishkin: Yeah, there, there’s a, there’s a wait list on snackbarstudio.com. But, I mean, to be honest, I, my, my expectation is we’re going to make a, a version of the game available to people like you and Michael first.
Finn Thormeier: So, yeah, makes sense. Um, now, I had a question. When you had that moment that you wrote about, and it was definitely one of your, your blog post, I don’t know if it’s also in your book, when you’re in that, I think it’s a bar or, like, a brunch spot in San Diego, when you finally got that email, uh, from your bank, that...
Rand Fishkin: From the Free Cafe. Yes.
Finn Thormeier: Well, so, so Moz was sold. You made a bunch of money that was wired to your bank account. That was a lot of money. And you, you, you bought everyone’s tab, uh, at, at that place that you were eating at with your wife when you got that news. Did that change anything? Because you were already running SparkToro at the time, and you were running, already running it with this calm company in mind. But did that windfall change anything with you, in terms of your energy, your attitude, anxiety, like, how tightly your fists were clenched? I don’t know, like, does that something...
Rand Fishkin: Absolutely, absolutely. So I would say the big, the big thing that changed was anxiety, fear, willingness to be a little more risky. Which, which actually, I’m going to say this too, because my financial situation changed so dramatically, but Casey’s, my co-founders, didn’t. There was a little bit of, like, tension and friction in there. Not, not in a bad way, but, like, you know, Casey kind of had this, as you would, a reasonable conversation, which is, “Hey man, you’re willing to take these risks because, you know, you have millions of dollars to fall back on. I don’t. Like, I got to get my kids, my girls, through college. We got to pay for our mortgage. Like, I, I am not comfortable taking some of these risks.” And I have defaulted to not making decisions that Casey is uncomfortable with, because I know that we’re in two different situations. And so, you know, I want to do some riskier stuff around pricing. I wanted to try some riskier product moves. Casey didn’t feel comfortable with it. I backed off. I was like, “You know what, that’s totally fine. We’ll do some less risky things that we think will still move the needle. Let’s work on those instead. I don’t want to, you know, I don’t want to blow up your spot.” And, and I obviously, I’d been in his exact situation for years, right? So, like, I get it.
Finn Thormeier: How necessary is this financial windfall for running a calm company?
Rand Fishkin: I mean, it helps, dude. I had, yeah, it definitely helps. But I, I did not, I did not have any money when I started SparkToro, right?
Finn Thormeier: And it was calm back then?
Rand Fishkin: Yeah. I, I mean, it was probably at, yeah, a similar, similar level of calm to what it is now. Maybe the first nine months were a little more intense, more fearful anyway, right? More like, “Oh my god, I hope this works.” But no, it wasn’t. It’s never been this high-intensity type of situation. And I’m sure that, you know, having that money absolutely helps me feel less anxiety around it, but I don’t think it is a requirement to start the company. It clearly wasn’t, right?
Finn Thormeier: Yeah. Yeah. So this, the, the podcast is called The Founder-Led Marketing Show, and obviously you are a master at that. You practice it at, at Moz, blogging, I think, five times a week, and now you’re practicing it on LinkedIn. How big or small would you judge having done that is playing into your success at Moz, that you grew so big, and at SparkToro, that you’re able to run a calm company and still grow and, and make meaningful revenue?
Rand Fishkin: I mean, brand builds on itself, right? So, you know, the, the brand, my personal
Brand, the fact that people know me and, and like me and trust me for years, the fact that I have lots of practice speaking, presenting, making visuals, diagramming things, working with big data, you know, making, making these charts and graphs from clickstream research. They had a huge impact. I, I couldn’t, I don’t think I could have done this in my, you know, early 20s. I, I think that the, both the brand value of, you know, all these people who followed me, and also the value of having done this for a long time and learned what works and doesn’t, especially what works for me with my audience: massive. Now, obviously, I’m challenging myself in the future with Snackbar, in a space I’m not familiar with, with a type of marketing I’m not familiar with, and that is going to be intense, right? So, we, we raised a couple million dollars for that business. Again, not from venture investors, right? And this kind of, I, I wouldn’t call Snackbar quite a calm company, but I would say it is. We are very anti-Crunch, for the, for people who are familiar with the video game world. Crunch is kind of this “make your artists and programmers work a hundred hours a week to get the Assassin’s Creed game out” and that, you know, in time, that kind of thing. And we’re, we’re super against that. Like, we’re much more calm.
Finn Thormeier: Mhm.
Rand Fishkin: Not as chill as SparkToro, but lower intensity. That, that team is only seven people, though we’ll probably add a couple more in the next year. But we raised, we raised a lot of money for it, relatively speaking, because I, I don’t have the same ability to move the needle personally that I could with SparkToro.
Finn Thormeier: Now, let’s say you, you have, you have, you’ve been in the space for a long time. You have 180,000 followers on LinkedIn. People know you. They know of Moz. They know of SparkToro. If you had to start at zero again, so you know everything that you learned, but you have zero followers, you have no brand. No one knows Rand Fishkin. You’re not this person that people have heard, especially in the SEO and search space. And you have to start from zero. And let’s say you’re still running SparkToro, you’re doing a million and a half in revenue, and you’re trying to grow it. What, what would you do? What would you focus on? How would you think about getting started from zero?
Rand Fishkin: I mean, there’s a bunch of questions I’d have about this, this, you know, fictional situation. Like, do I still have Amanda? Do people still follow her a bunch? You know, can I, can we use that?
Finn Thormeier: But no, you’re purely through sales, your network, events. No brand presence.
Rand Fishkin: No brand presence. Um, man, I am going to say I would almost certainly go out and try and hire someone who’s been there and done that before and who’s got that extra leg up, and then piggyback on top of that existing brand and, and influence, because...
Finn Thormeier: Well, you’re still, you’re still Rand, you still have your knowledge, so you’re still a marketer. You still...
Rand Fishkin: Yeah. So what I’m saying is, essentially, I would grow my brand new fresh brand.
Finn Thormeier: Yeah.
Rand Fishkin: Obviously in the same ways that I’m doing now, but I would piggyback on top of someone that I hired and brought to the team who had extensive brand familiarity, right? Because that, because I know the power of that personal brand, especially in this space, in the marketing technology space, reaching people who care about market research, audience research, social media marketing, content marketing, SEO, those kinds of practices. Like, you, you can feel it. There’s almost no brand you’ve heard of in the space where you don’t know the name of the people who are there.
Finn Thormeier: And as a result, you would hire basically a brand ambassador. You would find... How would you think about, um, like, um, incentivizing them, and, and, and compensating? Is their whole job just posting content and, and talking about the brand and the company?
Rand Fishkin: I think it’s, yeah, I think it’s content. I think it’s probably speaking and events. I think it’s probably videos. I think it’s, uh, social media posting. I think it’s also content on the website. It’s also informing the product, right? Like, I would want them to contribute to the product ideas and approve, you know, sort of like, as Casey and I are building things, they can look at it and say, “Yeah, that, that rocks. I’m so excited to post about that. Oh, I can’t wait to show that off to my network.” Because that, you can’t, there’s no substitute for that real excitement. Like, I, I don’t know, you know, how many people who are watching this have seen my videos about SparkToro, but you can tell that I have genuine effing excitement about certain things that we release. And other features, you know, no offense, I think they’re useful, people have asked us for them, but it’s more like, “Hey, we built this thing that people asked for and launched it. I don’t personally, like, vibe with it, but that’s fine.” And then other stuff where I’m like, “Dude, have you seen how cool this is?” You know, right? And that, I think that there, that difference is palpable.
Finn Thormeier: Now, I think you obviously have a lot of intuition around that, but I think, for the audience, maybe to get a little bit more tactical, would you focus on LinkedIn, post twice a week, talk about research that you did? Like, what would, like, that, and, and...
Rand Fishkin: YouTube. YouTube is a huge platform that I’ve underinvested in for years. I’ve talked to a bunch of people about YouTube, and I’m kind of starting fresh there. So I only have a, I don’t know, maybe 150 followers. I started there only six or eight weeks ago, which is embarrassing, right? I’ve had the, I should have been doing that for decades. Um, but I think that that’s a big opportunity. Uh, I would also probably be doing a lot of Reddit community marketing. I think that the internet is moving in Reddit’s direction, including in our space. And, like I mentioned, AI tools are obsessed with Reddit. Uh, this, this includes Gemini, which powers Google’s AI overviews. So, Reddit is just a huge place where I would be commenting and posting and talking about things. I, I’ve posted a couple of times to our Internet Is Beautiful with some of my data charts and gotten a million views, more than I’ve gotten on every other channel combined, with just a few hundred upvotes, like that. The, the ability of Reddit to rank in Google: like, someone does a Google image search for, you know, um, whatever, ChatGPT’s market share, and our stuff comes up, because I posted it to our Internet Is Beautiful, and, like, or, or Data Is Beautiful, and, like, just blew the f up.
It’s, uh, it’s sort of a cheat code. I, I would also, I cross-post to Blue Sky, Threads, and Twitter, and I would keep doing that. Uh, yes, I do. I disclose that I am randfish on, on Reddit, even though almost nobody is themselves on Reddit. I, I like to do it, and I post both for SparkToro and Snackbar there, and just sort of, I’ve always been myself on the internet, so I just feel comfortable doing that, and, uh, it’s sort of unique.
Finn Thormeier: I mean, that, that sounds like a lot. You mentioned LinkedIn and YouTube and Reddit, and then reposting to Blue Sky and all these other things. Is that also what your advice would be for someone who is starting out?
Rand Fishkin: No, no, no, no. See, those are things that I’m really good at. Like, so you said I still have my knowledge and experience.
Finn Thormeier: Yeah.
Rand Fishkin: Because I’m good at them, because I get them, I would keep doing that, right? Lean into your strengths. But if you are great at setting up a Google Ads campaign and just blowing out of the water with YouTube pre-roll, do that. And if you are fantastic at event marketing and meeting people in person and, you know, being at a booth, then do that. And if, if your strength is meme marketing on social media, lean into it. And if your strength is hiring people and agencies and, like, incentivizing them and working well with them, do that. So my advice is, you know, you can use these channels and platforms the way I do if, if that, if you’re good at that and you like doing that, but also you should lean into your own strengths.
Finn Thormeier: Do you think there’s any point in, if you’re a founder, and let’s say you’re a technical founder, so you, no marketing, no sales, you just love building product, do you think there’s any sense of trying to learn marketing and content and communication? Or should you just hire a marketer, and they do that, and you just forget about it?
Rand Fishkin: It really depends on who you are. There are some technical founders who end up being good at this stuff because their passion and their communication style resonates, and I would urge you to probably give it a try. Like, see if you are a right fit for those places. But 75, 80% of the time, when I’ve talked to technical founders, I’m like, “Yeah, that, you, you need your marketing, you know, charismatic, sort of emotionally intelligent, more people-focused, read, you know, read-the-internet-room, EQ type of person. That should probably be a co-founder,” right? This is, this is why Casey and I work really well together. Uh, I think that... Thank you for joining, really appreciate you. Um, by... Yeah, I, I think that if, if I were doing any other company... Snackbar, for example, my, my co-founders, right, the five of us, I’m the only person who doesn’t know how to make games. Like, the other four have done games, right? Important disclosure.
Finn Thormeier: All right, I’m here. Uh, Rand, this was awesome. Thank you so much for your time. Thank you for the, the awesome background and the, the, the stories. And, uh, everyone who was here, Chris, Mike, Inga who left, Michael, Tobi, Fad, thank you guys for your questions and for joining. And yeah, I’ll wrap it up here. Thank you, Rand.
Rand Fishkin: Thanks for having me, Finn. Take care, everybody. Bye-bye.












